TireCompare.com

Tire season guide

Best all-season tires USA — compare prices

All-season tires are the default for most American commuters — one set for dry highways, rain, and occasional light snow. Compare live prices from SimpleTire, Tires Easy, Giga Tires, and other US retailers, then filter any size page to all-season only.

What all-season tires do well

A modern all-season tire balances tread life, comfort, and traction from spring through fall. Touring lines like Michelin Defender2 and Continental TrueContact Tour target sedans and crossovers that rack up highway miles without seasonal tire swaps.

Performance all-season tires — Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4, for example — give sport sedans sharper handling while still handling light rain. They wear faster than touring tires but beat summer rubber in cool weather.

When all-season is not enough

If you commute through regular ice and deep snow in Minnesota, Michigan, or upstate New York, dedicated winter tires from November through March are safer than even the best all-season. The three-peak mountain snowflake (3PMSF) symbol means a tire passed a snow-traction test — helpful for occasional flurries, not a substitute for winters in snow-belt states.

How to compare all-season prices

Open your tire size on TireCompare — 225/65R17 and 235/45R18 are among the most searched US fitments — and use the season filter. Confirm model name, load index, and speed rating on the retailer checkout. Installation is usually $15–$30 per tire at partner shops, billed separately from the tire price.

Touring vs performance all-season: the choice most buyers skip

Touring all-season tires prioritize tread life, a quiet ride, and fuel economy. The Michelin Defender2, Continental TrueContact Tour, and Goodyear Assurance MaxLife all carry 70,000–80,000 mile treadwear warranties and suit sedans and crossovers that accumulate highway miles without aggressive driving.

Performance all-season tires — Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4, Continental ExtremeContact DWS06+, Yokohama ADVAN Sport A/S+ — trade some tread life for sharper steering response and better lateral grip. They fit sport sedans and drivers who want a more engaged feel without the cold-weather risk of summer tires. Expect 30,000–50,000 miles rather than 65,000+.

Decide before you price-shop. A touring tire that costs $20 more per tire than a performance option is the better value if touring characteristics match how you drive.

What UTQG treadwear ratings actually tell you

Every US tire sold with a UTQG rating carries a treadwear number — 400, 600, 700, and so on. Higher numbers indicate more durable tread compounds relative to the government reference tire. A 700-rated tire should outlast a 400-rated tire, but the numbers are not mileage guarantees and are not comparable across manufacturers.

Manufacturer treadwear warranties are more actionable. A Michelin Defender2 backed by a 70,000-mile treadwear warranty is a real commitment — Michelin will prorate credit if the tire wears before that. A UTQG number without a manufacturer warranty is just a relative indication. When comparing all-season tires, check both the UTQG number and whether a mileage warranty is offered.

Regional advice

  • Snow-belt states (MN, WI, MI, NY, ME)Run dedicated winter tires in cold months even if your all-season carries 3PMSF. Swap back to all-season in spring to preserve tread life.
  • Sun Belt (FL, AZ, TX Gulf, SoCal)Quality all-season tires are sufficient year-round. Focus on wet traction ratings if you drive in heavy summer rain.
  • Mountain West (CO, UT, WY passes)All-season works in Denver city driving; carry winters or chains for I-70 and mountain passes per local chain laws.

Compare all-season tires by size

Open any size to filter results to all-season tires from US retailers.

Buying tips

  • 3PMSF symbol Many modern all-season tires carry the three-peak mountain snowflake for light winter use — not a substitute for dedicated winter tires in heavy snow states.
  • Tread life vs grip Touring all-season tires prioritize mileage; performance all-season tires trade some tread life for sharper handling.
  • Compare before you buy four The same tire model can differ by $30–$60 per tire between retailers. Check at least three sources on TireCompare before checkout.

FAQ

Are all-season tires good enough for winter?

In mild climates (Florida, Southern California, Texas Gulf Coast), quality all-season tires are usually sufficient. In the Northeast, Upper Midwest, and mountain West, dedicated winter tires are safer November through March.

How much do all-season tires cost in the USA?

Passenger all-season tires commonly run $80–$200 per tire before installation. Compare live prices by size on TireCompare — installation is typically $15–$25 per tire at partner shops.

What does the 3PMSF snowflake mean?

It indicates the tire met a minimum snow-traction test. It helps in light snow but does not replace a winter tire for regular ice and deep snow commuting.

How long do all-season tires last?

Touring all-season tires often last 50,000–70,000 miles with rotation. Performance all-season tires may wear in 30,000–45,000 miles depending on driving style.

Can I mix all-season brands?

Match size, load index, and speed rating on each axle. Mixing brands on one axle is acceptable; mixing tire types (all-season vs winter) is not.

Which vehicles use all-season tires most?

Honda Accord, Toyota Camry, CR-V, RAV4, and Ford F-150 are top US searches. Open our vehicle pages for OEM sizes and live comparison links.

Related guides & pages

Other tire seasons